Pick a Label. Any Label. Please!

I’ve been thinking about labels a lot lately.  This is not something that I’ve done a lot of in the past.  I think the majority of people don’t think about labels all that much.  I find the whole label thing troublesome and constricting.  Either or, never both, black and white.  Too narrow.  I carried the label lesbian around for a long time, along with its sub-labels, dyke and butch.  I never liked it.  It felt foreign to me and separated me from other people who didn’t own a label like that.  Straight, cis-gender folks don’t need labels.  They’re simply women and men, husbands and wives, girlfriends, boyfriends, sisters, brothers, mothers, fathers, accountants, plumbers, nurses, teachers, widget makers and fire fighters.  They don’t need to qualify their sexuality along with those titles, as in, I’m a cis-gender heterosexual female civics teacher who’s brother is a cis-gender male heterosexual proctologist.  Honestly, who does that?  No one.  But we feel a need to label ourselves.  Transgender butch pansexual ballerina.  Who cares?  Really?  Unless you want to date the person, does it really matter?  Labels are tedious.

I realize that I’m speaking blasphemy here.  We’re all into our labels.  They make us unique and define who we are.  But have you ever noticed how much angst people put into finding just the right label to describe themselves?  I have.  And I’ve been doing it too.  I’ve been preparing for the day when someone asks me what I am.  Maybe it’ll be a little child in a restaurant innocently asking me if I’m a boy or a girl.  Maybe it will be a frightened woman in the restroom questioning me on whether I deserve to share the same toilet space as her.  Perhaps it will be a store clerk not sure if she should call me sir or ma’am.  And what will I say to them?  I don’t know.  What am I?  I feel like a hybrid man/woman/butch/transman.  Where do I belong?  Everywhere.  And nowhere.

Labels help us feel connected in community.  The lesbian community.  The trans community.  The LGBTQ community.  The African American community.  The Muslim community.  The deaf community.  You get the idea.  We keep separating ourselves and sequestering off into our little quadrants of the planet by label.  White, straight people don’t do that.  They don’t have to.  They have privilege and lawful rights that the rest of us are still fighting for.  Yet, by labeling ourselves, we separate ourselves from just being fellow human beings sharing a planet.  Are we really all that different?  I don’t think so.

If I refuse to label myself as a trans man does that make me not a trans man?  No.  If a deaf man refuses to label himself a deaf man, he’s still deaf.  But, what it does do is not set him apart from everyone else as “other”.  People often lead conversations with their labels.  Hi, I’m Shawn.  I’m a trans man.  Actually, I’m a transmasculine butch with a lesbian history.  I’m also Gold Star and proud of it!  Here’s my rainbow business card.  Go to my website and it will explain everything.  No, how about simply saying Hi, my name is Shawn.  It’s nice to meet you.

Then there’s pronouns and honorifics.  Sir/Ma’am, he/she/they/zir/etc.  At some point I’m going to have to pick pronouns.  And an identity.  I don’t want to.  I just want to be Shawn and have that be enough.  My neighbors don’t have to pick a label.  I don’t want to either.  Right now, I’m sure we’re known as the lesbian couple down the street. Why?  Because we’re perceived as different.  We’re not different.  We pay our bills, go to work, mow our lawns, have fights, go to the grocery, go on vacations, cook meals, play with our pets, care about our families, worry about our country, and everything else just like our neighbors do.  We’re not different.  The only difference is that we’re technically the same sex and they are the opposite.  So what?  Get over it.  I don’t want to be the lesbian couple next door.  I don’t want to be someone’s token lesbian friend.  Or trans friend either.  I’m really tired of all this othering that’s going on constantly.

The bathroom bills that are plaguing the country right now get me thinking about this even more.  If we were not seen as so different than the general population (i.e. white, cis-gender, straight people) where would all that fear come from?  People fear what they don’t understand, so we’re told.  They also fear what they’ve been taught to fear.  Fear breeds hate.  But, when it all comes down to it, we’re all just human animals that need to pee and aren’t trying to cause any trouble.  Our differences are being used to demonize us and make us seem like some thing vs. some one.  We’re people.  Bottom line.  We’re all just people.  And people need to pee.


7 thoughts on “Pick a Label. Any Label. Please!

  1. I find there are times when I use labels – trans, transgender, queer/queered, gay when they are expedient or when I wish to show solidarity with others. I like to think I control my usage of these terms, but I have sometimes allowed my boundaries to be violated, revealed more about myself than someone needed or deserved to know. However, I am adamant that I do not “identify” as trans (-gender, -sexual) any more than I “identify” as bipolar. It is what it is and, as with my mental health diagnosis, it is not everyone’s business. I do identify as queer and as gay, but I do not think of those as generic terms, I appreciate it when I have an opportunity to define the way/reasons I apply those terms to myself.

    It’s tricky, a bit of a semantic minefield at times. 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    • If we could all be more like dogs the world would be a much happier place, I think. They don’t care what breed or color other dogs are. They just want to play and have fun. Eat, play, sleep. Ah, the life of a dog!

      I know what you’re saying and I’m sure that there are times that it’s frustrating to get people to appreciate your disability and not just write you off as dumb. I can’t even imagine someone doing that to you but, then, I only know you through the written word. Still, it’s a disability, not who you are. It shouldn’t define you. Yes, it deserves respect and understanding as well as accommodation. But do you want to be known exclusively as the deaf person at work? I’m sure not. Yes, it is very very tricky indeed.

      Hugs to you and Remi!!

      Liked by 2 people

    • Not sure how that happened. That comment was meant for Kris.

      Anyway, roughghosts, I wanted to say, I agree completely. It’s very tricky and in a lot of cases necessary. Maybe in a perfect world we wouldn’t need labels but this is not a perfect world.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree with “roughhosts”, it is tricky, very tricky. Like you, I would also prefer to go label-less, but sometimes I need to label myself to get the other person to “get” me – and here I am referring to disability labels. “The worst thing about disability, is that people see it before they see you.” Hearing impaired not being “visible” (besides my hearing aids), I have to force this label down people’s throats sometimes in order for them to realize that I am not just/simply dumb (another label). I guess that quote also applies to us (setting us apart again) who are trans – “they” see “us” as trans or whatever, before “they” see the person. Sigh. I guess life and semantics are inextricably woven. Language started with labeling (I still maintain the first word a human ever used, was ‘dog’ and that it is the only word we really need! 😀 Wars and fights start with labels (let me shake off my philosophical cloak here!) And please forgive all the melodramatic quote punctuation in my comment. Ugh. More labels… Take care, Shawn, and thanks for sharing and expressing my thoughts once again. 🙂 Paw shake and a lick from Remi.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Everyone has multiple identities – by relationship (wife, mother, partner), profession (police officer, butcher, teacher), hobby, sexuality, etc. The thing is, if you are the in the dominant majority, you don’t think about it much – and you don’t hang it out on a shingle because it is assumed.
    If you don’t fit into that (and particularly if you are oppressed based on your minority status) then you identify by it or with it. Sometimes to excess. One sign of “assimilation” or “acceptance” is that people stop identifying as other – the point where immigrants disperse into the melting pot – or people start inter-marrying without dispute (e.g. Catholics with Protestants).
    My Jewishness is much easier to identify me by – there is Jewish law that states who is Jewish (my mother was so I am). My queerness/butchness/transness/pan-demi-poly is much harder because there is no queer law that has been around for 1000’s of years that clarifies it and everytime I think I nail it down, some 19 year old tells me I’m wrong.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Very true. Of course, religion is still a hot topic for a lot of folks. I know two couples who’s parents have never accepted their marriage based on differences in religions. (Catholic/Jewish, and Protestant/Greek Orthodox).

      It’s like trying to nail jello to the wall to figure some of this stuff out. It would be nice to be 19 again and have all the answers. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: What Do You Want to be When You Grow Up? | A Boy and Her Dog

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s